Skip to content
Weather forecastWeather data: CC BY 4.0; temperatures rounded
Advertise

Sections

DailyDigest

Our network

Europe News

Why Italy Is Becoming the G7’s Fiscal Role Model

Italy is borrowing more cheaply than France as its long record of primary surpluses offers a fiscal lesson for the wider G7.

Italy was once viewed as Europe’s fiscal warning sign. Now, new analysis suggests its long record of primary budget surpluses could offer a lesson to the rest of the G7, even as Rome prepares an election-year budget that may test its own discipline.

The shift is reflected in government bond markets. Italy is currently borrowing more cheaply than France, the UK and the United States, despite carrying one of the highest debt burdens in the eurozone. The development is an important part of the latest EU news and Europe’s wider debate over public finances, growth and borrowing costs.

Italy’s primary surplus gives it an unusual advantage

A primary surplus occurs when a government collects more in revenue than it spends before interest payments on existing debt are included. According to International Monetary Fund data, Italy has recorded a primary surplus in 28 of the 34 years since 1992.

That period began with a severe financial shock. In September 1992, the lira was forced out of the European exchange rate mechanism and lost value, prompting concerns over Italy’s ability to manage its public finances. The response was a prolonged effort to keep spending below revenue.

Janet Henry, global chief economist at HSBC, argues that the rest of the G7 may now need to adopt a similar approach. Her assessment is based on a straightforward debt calculation: when government borrowing costs remain above economic growth, debt tends to increase as a share of national output unless the state runs a primary surplus.

Henry does not describe Italy as a perfect example. Its public debt remains exceptionally high, but she says its advantage is consistency. Other major economies have only recently begun facing sustained pressure to improve their budget balances.

EU news: Italy is the only G7 economy forecast to run a surplus

The IMF’s October Fiscal Monitor highlights the contrast across the G7. Italy is projected to record a primary surplus of 1% of GDP in 2026, rising to 1.2% in 2027. It is the only G7 country expected to achieve a surplus over that period.

The other forecasts show primary deficits:

  • France: 2.9% of GDP in 2026
  • Germany: 3.4%
  • United States: 4.9%
  • Canada: 2.6%
  • Japan and the United Kingdom: about 1.2% each

Germany’s projected deficit reflects increased spending on defence and infrastructure, while France and the US face particularly difficult adjustments. Economist Zsolt Darvas has estimated that France and the United States would each need a primary surplus of 1.3% of GDP to stabilise their debt. The UK would need a surplus of 1.8%.

For France, that would require an improvement of more than four percentage points of GDP. Darvas noted that France has reached the necessary level only six times in the past five decades.

Bond markets are favouring Rome over Paris

One of the clearest signs of changing investor sentiment comes from sovereign debt markets. On 17 November, Italy’s 10-year government bond yield stood at 4.43%, compared with 4.93% for France’s equivalent bond.

That 50-basis-point difference means Italy can borrow more cheaply than France over a decade. The reversal is significant: at the beginning of 2025, Italy paid 34 basis points more than France. Their yields crossed in September 2025, after which the gap continued to move in Italy’s favour.

Italy’s borrowing costs were also below those of the UK and the US, whose 10-year yields were reported at 5.35% and 5.12% respectively. Against Germany, Italy’s benchmark BTP-Bund spread was 106 basis points, while France’s equivalent spread was 156 basis points.

Investors are not treating Italy as risk-free. Its spread over German debt widened from about 60 basis points in late February as higher energy prices and inflation expectations pushed borrowing costs higher across Europe. However, economists at Pantheon Macroeconomics expect the spread to narrow substantially by mid-2027.

Italy’s debt remains a major vulnerability

Lower relative borrowing costs do not erase Italy’s debt problem. The IMF expects Italian public debt to reach 137.9% of GDP in 2026, the highest level in the eurozone and slightly above Greece’s projected 136%.

Italy’s fiscal plan anticipates debt rising further to 138.5% of GDP in 2027. The government expects the deficit to reach 2.9% of GDP this year and 3.4% next year, partly because of additional defence and energy spending permitted under EU rules.

This distinction matters for anyone following European current affairs: a primary surplus can slow the growth of debt, but it does not automatically reduce the total debt stock. High interest costs can continue to weigh on public finances even when day-to-day government spending is controlled.

Election-year tax cuts will test Rome’s strategy

Italy’s 2027 budget, approved by Giorgia Meloni’s government on 28 October and now before Parliament, is worth approximately €26 billion. Much of the package involves tax relief, including a temporary extension of the 33% income-tax band to earnings of €55,000.

Other measures include:

  • A 1% tax rate on certain pay rises for younger private-sector workers earning up to €28,000
  • A 5% rate on some renewed-contract increases for workers earning up to €33,000
  • An increase in the turnover limit for the self-employed flat-tax regime from €85,000 to €100,000
  • The removal of car tax for one insured vehicle of up to 80 kilowatts per owner
  • A tax-free monthly payment of €100 for eligible mothers with two or more children

Banks and insurers would help fund the measures through a temporary three-point increase in corporate income tax. Energy companies would face a higher regional business tax, while the tax on financial transactions would double to 0.8%.

Italy’s Court of Auditors warned lawmakers on 9 November that many tax measures expire at the end of 2027 and that around 70% of the funding is non-recurring. That could leave a significant budgetary challenge for the next Parliament.

What the latest Europe news means for Italy

Italy’s fiscal record has improved its standing with investors, but the country is not yet a model of low debt. Its challenge is to preserve primary surpluses while responding to pressure for tax cuts, public investment and higher defence spending.

That pressure is intensifying ahead of a general election expected by autumn 2027, with speculation about an earlier vote. A SWG poll published on 9 November placed the centre-left opposition on 44.9% and Meloni’s centre-right coalition on 44%, within the margin of error.

The central question is whether Italy can maintain the budget discipline that has reassured bond markets while delivering promises that may increase future spending. The answer will shape not only Italian economic policy but also the wider debate over EU current affairs and fiscal sustainability across Europe.

The takeaway: Italy’s experience shows that decades of primary surpluses can change how investors assess a heavily indebted country. But the 2027 budget will reveal whether Rome can remain the G7’s fiscal outlier while entering an increasingly competitive election cycle.

Suggested stories

Join the conversation

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Guide & Tools