Skip to content
Weather forecastWeather data: CC BY 4.0; temperatures rounded
Advertise

Sections

DailyDigest

Our network

Europe News

Apple to Face French Trial Over Alleged iPhone Repair Obstruction

Apple will face a Paris trial in June 2027 over allegations that software restrictions obstructed independent repairs on several iPhone models.

Apple is set to face a landmark trial in France over allegations that software restrictions made it harder to repair or refurbish certain iPhone models outside the company’s authorised network. The case is among the most significant pieces of European news involving consumer rights, technology regulation and planned obsolescence.

French prosecutors accuse Apple Distribution International and Apple Inc of obstructing repairs for more than two and a half years. Apple denies the allegations, saying they are unfounded.

Apple trial in France scheduled for June 2027

The four-day hearing is due to begin in Paris on 17 June 2027, according to a source close to the case cited by AFP. The proceedings follow a complaint filed in December 2022 by Stop Planned Obsolescence, a campaign group that focuses on products allegedly designed to have shorter useful lifespans.

The group described the prosecution as a first against Apple for alleged obstruction of repair and refurbishment. The case could become an important test of how French authorities apply consumer-protection rules to software-controlled hardware repairs.

The allegations cover several iPhone families sold during the period from November 2021 to July 2024, including:

  • iPhone XS models;
  • iPhone 12, 13, 14 and 15 series devices; and
  • the iPhone SE released in 2022.

What Apple is accused of doing

Prosecutors allege that Apple configured software in a way that could prevent independent repairers from fully restoring or maintaining affected phones. The accusation centres on parts replaced outside Apple’s authorised repair network.

Examples cited in the case include Face ID becoming unavailable after an unauthorised camera replacement, or the battery-health function no longer operating normally after a battery repair. If proven, such restrictions could make consumers more dependent on official outlets or encourage them to replace a phone rather than repair it.

Apple has rejected the claims. The company told AFP: “We strongly contest these unfounded allegations.” The trial will determine whether the software behaviour amounted to unlawful obstruction rather than a technical or security measure.

What planned obsolescence means

Planned obsolescence generally refers to practices that deliberately shorten a product’s usable life, potentially encouraging customers to buy replacements sooner. In the technology sector, the issue can involve hardware durability, software support, spare parts, repair access or restrictions placed on non-original components.

The French case is focused specifically on alleged barriers to repair and refurbishment. It does not establish that Apple is guilty, and the allegations will need to be examined in court.

Potential financial consequences

If convicted, Apple could face a fine of up to €300,000, together with an additional penalty of as much as 5% of annual revenue. Based on the figure reported in connection with the case, that additional amount could be roughly €21.7 billion.

Customers could also pursue compensation claims, although any such claims would be separate from the criminal proceedings and would depend on further legal steps. The possible financial exposure makes the case relevant to wider EU news about corporate accountability and consumer rights, even though it is being brought under French law.

Apple has faced earlier action over iPhone software

This is not the first legal dispute between Apple and Stop Planned Obsolescence. In February 2021, Apple agreed to pay €25 million after failing to tell iPhone users that software updates could slow older devices.

That settlement followed Apple’s admission in December 2017 that its iOS software reduced the performance of some older iPhones when their batteries had deteriorated. Apple said the measure was intended to prevent unexpected shutdowns, but the lack of clear information prompted legal and consumer criticism.

The new French trial concerns a different alleged practice: whether software-linked component restrictions obstructed repairs carried out outside Apple’s approved network.

Why the case matters for European technology regulation

The proceedings arrive as repairability and product longevity become increasingly important themes in European politics and consumer policy. The outcome could influence how manufacturers explain repair limitations, authenticate replacement parts and design software features linked to hardware components.

For consumers, the central question is whether owning a phone includes a meaningful ability to have it repaired by a provider of their choice. For manufacturers, the case raises questions about device security, reliability and the use of software controls after a component has been replaced.

The court will now have to assess the evidence, the technical operation of the affected iPhones and the purpose of the restrictions alleged by prosecutors. Until judgment is delivered, the claims against Apple remain allegations.

The key takeaway

Apple’s planned French trial will examine whether software restrictions on selected iPhones unlawfully made independent repair and refurbishment more difficult. With potentially substantial fines and possible consumer compensation claims at stake, the case could become a major development in European news about the right to repair and the responsibilities of technology companies.

Suggested stories

Join the conversation

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Guide & Tools