Shay Given has revealed that Ireland manager Heimir Hallgrímsson is particularly frustrated by the individual mistakes that have undermined promising performances during the UEFA Nations League campaign. Speaking on RTÉ ahead of Ireland’s meeting with Kosovo, the former goalkeeper said the team must become more streetwise and learn how to win matches without always producing a perfect display.
The comments came as Ireland prepared for a crucial Nations League fixture at the Aviva Stadium, following a narrow 1-0 defeat by Austria. Ireland had created several chances in Linz but failed to convert them, while a previous 2-2 draw at home against the same opposition had also left the side needing a stronger result.
Shay Given identifies Ireland’s key weakness
Given said Hallgrímsson had highlighted costly individual errors in conversation with him. The former Republic of Ireland international explained that the manager wants his players to show greater awareness in important moments rather than trying to play their way out of every situation.
According to Given, Hallgrímsson’s message is that Ireland must be prepared to “win ugly” when necessary. That does not mean abandoning an attacking approach; instead, it means protecting a lead, making sensible decisions under pressure and prioritising the result when the match becomes difficult.
That issue has been evident in Ireland’s recent performances. The team has produced encouraging passages of play and created opportunities, but mistakes at either end of the pitch have proved expensive. For a side competing in a tight group, those small lapses can determine whether a promising display produces points.
Ireland’s attacking play offers encouragement
Richie Sadlier was more positive about the direction of the team, despite the mixed results. The analyst pointed to several moments that showed Ireland were creating the situations required to score, including a ball from Adam Idah across the goal towards Nathan Collins and an Ogbene header late in the match.
Sadlier’s assessment was that Ireland need to reduce their mistakes while recognising that not every outcome can be controlled. Football can turn on a deflection, a missed chance or a goalkeeper’s save, but Ireland’s margin for error has been reduced by the points already dropped.
- Ireland have created chances in recent matches but have not always taken them.
- Individual errors have contributed to difficult results.
- Hallgrímsson wants the team to show greater game management.
- A win against Kosovo would strengthen Ireland’s position in the group.
Why the Kosovo fixture matters
The Kosovo match carried significance beyond the immediate Nations League table. Ireland were also seeking a strong seeding position ahead of the Euro 2028 qualifying campaign, which will be staged in the wider context of the tournament being hosted across Ireland, the United Kingdom and Northern Ireland.
Nations League promotion remained possible if Ireland defeated Kosovo and secured second place in the group. That gave the fixture an added competitive edge, with the result potentially influencing both Ireland’s short-term prospects and their position going into future international competition.
Ireland were also forced to make a defensive change, with John Egan coming into the centre of defence in place of captain Nathan Collins. The adjustment added another test for a team already under pressure to eliminate avoidable errors.
Hallgrímsson seeking a more resilient Ireland
Hallgrímsson’s reported frustration is not necessarily a criticism of Ireland’s overall style. Instead, it reflects the difference between playing well and managing a match effectively. Ireland have shown signs of progress in their general play, but the manager wants that improvement to be matched by greater composure in both penalty areas.
For Ireland, the challenge against Kosovo was therefore clear: create chances, avoid overplaying the ball and make the decisive moments count. The side did not need to dominate every phase of the match if it could demonstrate the discipline to protect its advantage and secure the result.
Shay Given’s assessment underlined the central lesson from Ireland’s recent campaign. Good performances provide a foundation, but international football rewards teams that make fewer mistakes and find ways to win when conditions are not ideal. For Hallgrímsson, that resilience will be essential as Ireland pursue Nations League progress and prepare for the Euro 2028 qualifiers.

