Skip to content
Weather forecastWeather data: CC BY 4.0; temperatures rounded
Advertise

Sections

DailyDigest

Our network

News

Presbyterian Church accepts unlawful processing of Sandymount elder’s data

The Presbyterian Church in Ireland accepts DPC findings that it unlawfully processed data belonging to former Sandymount elder Steven Smyrl.

The Presbyterian Church in Ireland has accepted findings from the Data Protection Commission (DPC) that it unlawfully processed the personal data of Steven Smyrl, a former elder at Christ Church Sandymount in Dublin.

The regulator upheld two complaints made by Smyrl, who said confidential documents containing sensitive information about him were shared beyond the church commission that was meant to examine his case. The findings bring a data protection issue into focus within a dispute that followed his same-sex marriage.

What the DPC found about the Sandymount case

Smyrl was formally removed as an elder at Christ Church Sandymount in September 2019, following his same-sex marriage in 2018 and an internal investigation by a Presbyterian Church commission.

During that inquiry, he provided two confidential documents in support of his position:

  • A personal statement written by Smyrl.
  • A letter of support from the church’s minister and council secretary.

The documents were intended for the six members of the investigating commission. Under the Presbyterian Church’s own rules, material submitted to a commission is confidential and should not be disclosed to other parties.

The DPC said the church failed to demonstrate a lawful basis for the further processing of Smyrl’s personal data contained in the letter of support. It also found that the church had not demonstrated a lawful basis for including additional special-category personal data in a letter retracting allegedly defamatory statements.

Church accepts Ireland data protection findings

In a statement acknowledging the DPC’s conclusions, the Presbyterian Church in Ireland said it was committed to improving its processes and procedures to ensure full compliance in the future.

The regulator also expressed regret for the delay in dealing with Smyrl’s complaints. Its findings noted that a data controller or processor may potentially face liability for damages in the courts if it fails to observe its duty of care in relation to personal data in its possession.

The DPC stressed that any person who believes their data protection rights may have been breached must decide whether to seek legal advice. The regulator’s comments do not themselves determine compensation or provide a damages award.

Smyrl said he intended to take legal advice about possible redress for the harm he believes was caused by the church’s handling of his case.

Welcoming the DPC’s findings, he described the sharing of information supplied in confidence as deeply disturbing. He said he had been taken aback to discover that highly personal information was subsequently shared with others without his consent.

Smyrl said the experience had been humiliating and argued that the church appeared to show little regard for the privacy and dignity of individuals whose lives did not conform to its doctrines. Those comments are his view of the events and the church’s conduct.

Why confidential church records matter

The case illustrates the importance of clear data governance when organisations investigate internal complaints or disciplinary matters. Sensitive personal data requires a lawful basis for processing, and confidentiality rules must be reflected in how documents are stored, circulated and used.

For organisations handling information about relationships, religious beliefs, health or other protected matters, the consequences of improper disclosure can extend beyond administrative concerns. The DPC’s findings underline that internal procedures do not remove data protection responsibilities.

Key points from the DPC decision

  • The complaints concerned personal data processed by the Presbyterian Church in Ireland.
  • The documents had been submitted for the attention of a six-member investigating commission.
  • The DPC found that the church had not shown a lawful basis for certain further processing.
  • The regulator also identified concerns about additional special-category personal data.
  • Smyrl is considering legal advice regarding potential redress.

The Presbyterian Church’s acceptance of the findings marks a significant development in the Sandymount elder’s long-running dispute. The central issue now is whether further legal steps will follow and what remedies, if any, may be available to Smyrl.

For readers following Irish news, the case is a reminder that data protection obligations apply to religious organisations and other bodies when they handle confidential personal information. The clear takeaway is that sensitive records must be processed lawfully, shared only where justified and protected in line with both internal confidentiality rules and Irish data protection law.

Suggested stories

Join the conversation

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Guide & Tools