Skip to content
Weather forecastWeather data: CC BY 4.0; temperatures rounded
Advertise

Sections

DailyDigest

Our network

Europe News

Macron Calls for Ukraine NATO Membership Debate to Reopen

Emmanuel Macron says Europe should reopen the question of Ukraine joining NATO, as allies debate security guarantees and a possible post-war settlement.

French President Emmanuel Macron has called for the question of Ukraine’s NATO membership to be reopened, arguing that the country’s future security will be central to Europe’s long-term defence. His comments came after a meeting of the Coalition of the Willing in Berlin, co-chaired by France and the United Kingdom.

The intervention adds a significant new dimension to European discussions about possible peace arrangements and security guarantees for Kyiv. Macron also urged Ukraine’s allies to do the maximum to supply the air-defence systems it needs.

Macron says Ukraine’s NATO option should be reconsidered

Macron said Ukraine’s accession to NATO had been set aside in early 2022, but stressed that the circumstances were now “completely different”. He argued that Russia’s position remained maximalist and that European governments needed to think beyond the immediate phase of the war.

“The question arises, including for us Europeans, of what happens the day after,” Macron said. In his view, Ukraine is likely to emerge from the conflict with a large and well-equipped military, making its relationship with NATO an important issue for European security.

The comments represent support for reopening the debate, rather than an announcement that Ukraine is about to join the alliance. NATO membership would still require agreement among all member states, while the conflict and its eventual settlement remain unresolved.

Why Ukraine’s NATO membership was previously ruled out

After Russia launched its full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022, Western allies ruled out Kyiv joining NATO in the short term. The central concern was that admitting a country at war with Russia could create a direct confrontation between NATO and Moscow under Article 5, the alliance’s collective-defence provision.

That position reflected the risks associated with extending the alliance’s security commitment while active fighting continued. Ukraine has nevertheless maintained that membership would provide the strongest long-term guarantee against another Russian attack.

Macron’s remarks suggest that some European leaders are now examining whether the strategic situation has changed sufficiently to revisit the issue, particularly in the context of potential negotiations.

Peace talks put security guarantees back in focus

The NATO question gained renewed attention after two days of US-mediated peace talks in Abu Dhabi on 10 and 11 November. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said US negotiators had raised the possibility of Ukraine withdrawing from parts of the eastern Donbas region in exchange for NATO membership.

Zelenskyy said Kyiv was not prepared to surrender territory. However, he confirmed that discussions were taking place about specific security guarantees involving NATO and the European Union.

He also said that any such proposal would need to be put to Ukrainian society. Zelenskyy stated that he had no right to make the decision alone, underlining the political and constitutional sensitivity of any agreement involving territory or national security.

What could happen next?

Macron’s intervention does not settle the question of membership, but it places NATO accession firmly among the options being discussed by Ukraine’s European partners. Several issues would need to be addressed before the proposal could advance:

  • Whether an eventual peace settlement would meet the conditions required for NATO membership.
  • How collective defence commitments would apply while disputed territories remained unresolved.
  • Whether all NATO members would support opening an accession process.
  • How membership would interact with separate security guarantees from European countries and the EU.
  • Whether Ukrainian voters would approve any agreement involving territory or military commitments.

The debate is therefore likely to remain tied to the wider negotiations over the war’s outcome, rather than moving immediately towards a formal accession timetable.

European security implications

Macron framed Ukrainian membership as a matter of long-term European security, not only as a response to Russia’s invasion. His argument is that a militarily capable Ukraine could become a key part of Europe’s future defence architecture if it received credible guarantees and a defined place within Western security structures.

His comments followed a meeting of the Coalition of the Willing in Berlin and came on the same day as a trilateral meeting involving Russian President Vladimir Putin, US President Donald Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping in China. These developments place European leaders under pressure to clarify how they would respond to any future settlement and what role Europe would play in enforcing or supporting it.

For now, Ukraine’s NATO accession remains a political question rather than an agreed policy. Macron’s call to reopen the issue indicates that European governments are preparing to examine security arrangements beyond the immediate battlefield, while Kyiv continues to insist that its sovereignty and territorial integrity cannot simply be traded away.

Conclusion

Macron’s call to reopen Ukraine’s NATO membership debate marks an important shift in the discussion about Europe’s future security. It does not guarantee accession, but it shows that NATO membership is again being considered alongside other security guarantees as allies assess what comes after the war. The decisive issues will be the terms of any peace agreement, the position of NATO members and the consent of Ukrainian society.

Suggested stories

Join the conversation

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Guide & Tools