Skip to content
Weather forecastWeather data: CC BY 4.0; temperatures rounded
Advertise

Sections

DailyDigest

Our network

Breaking News

115 Groups Urge Government to Scrap Proposed Citizenship Changes

A coalition of 115 organisations is urging the Government to abandon proposed changes that would make Irish citizenship harder to obtain.

Proposed changes to Irish citizenship requirements have come under renewed pressure after 115 organisations called on the Government to abandon the plans. The coalition says extending the residency requirement, introducing new tests and tightening financial rules could make citizenship harder to secure for migrants who have built their lives in Ireland.

The joint statement was presented at Leinster House on Thursday as part of the Citizenship is Belonging campaign. Trade unions, civil society organisations, community groups and faith bodies were among those supporting the call for the proposals to be withdrawn.

What the proposed citizenship changes would do

The proposals, associated with Minister for Justice Jim O’Callaghan, would alter several parts of the route to Irish citizenship. The changes outlined by campaigners include:

  • Increasing the residence requirement from five years to eight years
  • Introducing a language and civics test
  • Applying financial self-sufficiency rules that could affect people who have received social welfare payments

Supporters of the campaign argue that the measures would create additional barriers for people who are already working, paying taxes and participating in Irish communities. They also say the proposals could create uncertainty for applicants who have spent years planning their future around the existing framework.

Citizenship changes leave migrants uncertain about their future

Sumyrah Khan, who arrived in Ireland six years ago on a scholarship for a master’s degree in international relations, said she remains unsure about what lies ahead. She is now in full-time employment with the Irish Network Against Racism.

Khan said migrants felt that the Government was “constantly moving the goalposts” and had not properly explained why the changes were being proposed. She described the effect as reducing migrants to economic units, rather than recognising their wider contribution to communities and public life.

Her concerns centre on the uncertainty created by a possible longer wait for citizenship. Although she has worked continuously in public service and contributed to migrant rights work, she said she still does not know what the future holds for her in Ireland.

The Citizenship is Belonging campaign says this uncertainty is one of the central problems with the proposed reforms. Its supporters argue that citizenship is not only an administrative status but also a form of belonging and participation in Irish society.

Organisations challenge the Government’s approach

Representatives from the Immigrant Council of Ireland, Migrant Rights Centre Ireland, the Ukraine Civil Society Forum and Doras were among those calling for the proposals to be cancelled.

The organisations described the changes as unfair, unjust and unnecessary. They argued that creating additional barriers could exclude people who contribute to workplaces, cultural life and local communities, weakening rather than strengthening social cohesion.

Migrant Rights Centre Ireland director Neil Bruton also linked the proposals to wider questions about Ireland’s demographic and economic needs. He referred to reports including the Department of Finance’s Future Forty report and the National Economic and Social Council’s Building a Virtuous Demographic Cycle report.

According to Bruton, those reports point to the need to attract and retain migrants because of Ireland’s ageing population and low birth rate. He argued that the proposed citizenship rules conflict with that objective by making long-term settlement less certain.

Ukrainian residents raise separate citizenship concerns

The campaign has also highlighted the position of Ukrainians living in Ireland under the temporary protection scheme. Time spent in Ireland under that arrangement cannot be counted towards a citizenship application, according to the Ukraine Civil Society Forum.

Brian Killoran said this was unfair given the contribution made by displaced Ukrainians since Russia’s invasion. He said about 82,500 people displaced by the war remained in Ireland, with approximately 30 per cent under the age of 20.

He also said that 16,000 Ukrainian children were attending schools across the country. In addition, Killoran identified a working-age cohort of up to 55,000 Ukrainians, including 32,000 people in full-time employment.

Campaigners argue that these figures demonstrate why citizenship and residency policy must account for people’s practical contribution to Irish life, as well as the legal category under which they first arrived.

What happens next?

The joint statement represents organised opposition to the proposals, but the source material does not indicate that the Government has withdrawn them or set out a revised timetable. The debate is therefore likely to continue as campaign groups press the Minister for Justice to reconsider the planned changes.

For migrants, the immediate concern is that a longer residency period and additional eligibility requirements could delay citizenship applications and complicate long-term plans. For the Government, the issue involves balancing the design of citizenship rules with broader immigration, integration and workforce policy.

The dispute now places the Government under pressure to explain the evidence behind the proposed reforms and how they would affect people who have already established homes, careers and community ties in Ireland.

Key takeaway on Ireland’s citizenship debate

The 115 organisations opposing the proposals say the planned Irish citizenship changes would create exclusion and uncertainty, particularly through a longer residency requirement, new tests and financial conditions. With campaigners also raising the position of Ukrainians under temporary protection, the Government faces growing calls to reconsider how citizenship policy supports belonging and long-term integration.

Suggested stories

Join the conversation

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Guide & Tools