Skip to content
Weather forecastWeather data: CC BY 4.0; temperatures rounded
Advertise

Sections

DailyDigest

Our network

Europe News

Berset Warns Europe’s Migration Crackdown Must Respect Human Rights

Council of Europe chief Alain Berset says tougher European migration policies must respect human rights as five EU countries plan a Rwanda return hub.

Alain Berset, Secretary General of the Council of Europe, has warned that tougher migration controls must not come at the expense of human rights. His comments come as five EU countries prepare to work with Rwanda on a return hub for rejected asylum seekers, placing the plans at the centre of Europe’s migration debate.

Speaking to Euronews on 17 November 2026, Berset said governments were entitled to tighten immigration policies, but remained bound by their international commitments. He rejected the idea that stronger border controls and respect for asylum rights were impossible to reconcile.

EU migration policy must remain grounded in human rights

Berset argued that the right to control migration does not remove a state’s responsibility to protect fundamental rights. He said European governments could deport people who had no legal basis to stay, provided the process complied with human rights standards.

“Human rights are human rights for everybody or for no one,” he said.

The Council of Europe is separate from the European Union, although all EU member states belong to the wider organisation. Its human rights framework, including the European Convention on Human Rights and the rulings of the European Court of Human Rights, remains an important reference point in discussions about asylum, deportation and detention.

Berset noted that the European Court of Human Rights had supported some expulsions while finding others unlawful. That distinction is central to the debate: human rights law does not create an unrestricted right to remain, but it does require governments to assess individual cases and avoid unlawful removal.

Return hub plans raise questions over European standards

The secretary general’s remarks followed an announcement by five EU countries of a partnership with Rwanda to establish a return hub for rejected asylum seekers. The proposal is intended to support the return of people whose asylum applications have been refused, but Berset questioned whether such arrangements would meet European human rights requirements.

He also expressed regret that preparations for the partnership appeared to have proceeded without continuing earlier discussions opened with the Council of Europe. His concern was not simply about the location of a possible return centre, but about whether accountability, legal safeguards and access to effective remedies would be maintained when migration procedures take place outside the EU.

Any external processing or return arrangement would therefore face scrutiny over issues including:

  • whether people can challenge removal decisions;
  • how asylum claims and appeals are assessed;
  • what protections apply to vulnerable people;
  • who is responsible for monitoring detention and living conditions; and
  • whether returns could expose individuals to persecution or serious harm.

What the warning means for Europe’s migration debate

Berset rejected suggestions that Europe was experiencing a migration crisis or that asylum had become politically unsustainable. Instead, he said governments should seek policies that are both effective and lawful.

That position reflects a continuing tension in European politics. Governments face pressure to reduce irregular migration and increase returns, while courts and human rights bodies insist that enforcement must respect due process and the principle of non-refoulement. The latter prevents states from sending people to places where they could face torture, persecution or other serious threats.

For EU countries, the debate also intersects with the implementation of the migration and asylum pact, cooperation with countries outside the bloc and efforts to strengthen external border management. The details of the Rwanda partnership, including its legal structure and safeguards, will determine how it is judged under European standards.

Berset said the rules-based order was essential to stability, peace and predictability. In his view, that principle must apply to migration policy as much as to other areas of European affairs. A government may change its immigration rules, but it cannot simply disregard the legal obligations that accompany them.

Why human rights safeguards will remain decisive

The disagreement surrounding return hubs is likely to focus on implementation rather than the broad principle that unsuccessful asylum applicants may be returned. European law allows returns in appropriate circumstances, but requires decisions to be lawful, individualised and subject to safeguards.

For people following Europe news today, the key question is whether the proposed arrangement can demonstrate those protections in practice. The Council of Europe’s intervention signals that political support for stricter migration policy will not settle the legal arguments.

The immediate significance of Berset’s warning is therefore twofold: governments retain room to pursue tougher migration measures, but externalisation cannot place human rights beyond effective oversight.

Conclusion

Berset’s message is clear: Europe can strengthen migration enforcement, but it cannot sideline human rights. As EU governments develop return partnerships with countries such as Rwanda, compliance with asylum law, court rulings and effective legal safeguards will determine whether those plans can withstand scrutiny. The future of EU migration policy will depend not only on how many returns are carried out, but on whether they are conducted within the rules-based system Europe says it aims to protect.

Suggested stories

Join the conversation

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Guide & Tools