Skip to content
Weather forecastWeather data: CC BY 4.0; temperatures rounded
Advertise

Sections

DailyDigest

Our network

Sports

Rassie Erasmus Predicts Sam Prendergast Will Face South Africa

Rassie Erasmus expects Sam Prendergast to face South Africa despite a reported citing over an alleged hip-drop tackle against Fiji.

Rassie Erasmus believes Sam Prendergast will be available for Ireland’s Nations Championship meeting with South Africa on Saturday, despite reports that the fly-half has been cited over an alleged hip-drop tackle against Fiji.

The South Africa head coach made the prediction while launching a broader criticism of rugby’s disciplinary process and the role of television match officials. Erasmus also raised questions about whether knowingly ignoring foul play could interfere with the outcome of a match, although he later stressed that he was not making an accusation against any official.

Sam Prendergast citing hangs over Ireland team selection

Prendergast was reported to the citing commissioner after Ireland’s 43-15 win over Fiji. His challenge on Fiji captain Peceli Yato has become the main disciplinary issue ahead of the match at the Aviva Stadium.

At the time of Erasmus’s comments on 16 November, the Nations Championship had not publicly confirmed the case or announced any suspension. That means Prendergast’s availability remained unresolved, although Erasmus said he expected the Ireland out-half to play.

“I think there is going to be a technicality and he is going to play,” Erasmus said, while acknowledging that he was trying to choose his words carefully.

He later added: “My gut feeling is he’ll play on Saturday.”

Rassie Erasmus criticises hip-drop tackle decisions

Erasmus was clear about his own view of the incident, describing the alleged hip-drop tackle as “terrible”. He said coaches had spent approximately three hours discussing the technique at a World Rugby meeting, where examples were used to explain the dangers and the sanctions available under the law.

However, World Rugby guidance does not make every hip-drop tackle an automatic red-card offence. The sanction depends on factors including the level of danger and the specific circumstances of the challenge.

Erasmus questioned why the TMO had not intervened during the match if the incident met the threshold for serious foul play. He said those watching the game believed it warranted an immediate red card.

His comments add another layer to the disciplinary debate surrounding Ireland rugby, with Prendergast’s case now an important part of the build-up to the South Africa fixture.

South Africa coach compares recent disciplinary cases

The Springboks coach also referred to South Africa’s previous experiences with disciplinary proceedings involving Lood de Jager, Jan-Hendrik Wessels and Franco Mostert. He said those cases had left him with an unfavourable impression of the process, while insisting that he was not claiming anyone had acted improperly.

Erasmus also revisited the recent case involving Ireland prop Tadhg Furlong. Furlong’s citing complaint was dismissed after an independent committee unanimously found that he had not committed foul play. Erasmus compared that outcome with a suspension previously issued to Wessels, presenting the comparison as part of his concern about consistency.

The cases are not identical, and the final decision on Prendergast will depend on the citing process and the evidence considered by the disciplinary panel.

Questions over TMO involvement and match officials

Erasmus widened his criticism by referring to South Africa’s defeat by France. He claimed that 17 knee-drop tackles had been made against his players without punishment, using that example to argue for stronger TMO involvement.

He posed conditional questions about whether an official who saw foul play but chose not to act could be affecting the result of a match. When challenged on the seriousness of the suggestion, Erasmus repeated that he was not making an accusation.

His central argument was that TMOs should not be discouraged from intervening when player safety or a significant disciplinary decision is involved. In his view, limiting their involvement could lead to injuries or an incorrect result.

What happens next for Ireland?

Ireland’s immediate priority is clarity over Prendergast’s status. The team will need to know whether the citing leads to a hearing, a suspension or clearance before final selection decisions are made.

  • No suspension had been confirmed when Erasmus made his comments.
  • The alleged incident occurred during Ireland’s win over Fiji.
  • World Rugby’s framework allows different sanctions for hip-drop tackles.
  • South Africa will meet Ireland at the Aviva Stadium on Saturday.

Prendergast’s potential absence would create a significant selection question for Ireland, but Erasmus’s prediction is not a disciplinary ruling. Until the relevant process is completed, his involvement remains uncertain.

The controversy ensures that the Ireland-South Africa clash will carry an additional storyline beyond the result. The disciplinary decision, the use of the TMO and the interpretation of the hip-drop law will all be under close scrutiny.

Key takeaway for Ireland rugby supporters

Rassie Erasmus expects Sam Prendergast to play against South Africa, but the Ireland fly-half’s position will only be settled by the official disciplinary process. Erasmus’s comments have intensified the debate over hip-drop tackles, TMO intervention and consistency in rugby’s laws, making the decision one of the central talking points before Saturday’s match.

Suggested stories

Join the conversation

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Guide & Tools