A former Air Corps commandant has told the Court of Appeal that his conviction for assaulting a superior officer was a miscarriage of justice, alleging that senior Defence Forces officers encouraged a complaint against him.
Nile Donohoe, from Watergrange in Co Kildare, is seeking permission to introduce new or newly discovered evidence in an attempt to reopen the case, which dates back to an incident at Casement Aerodrome in Baldonnell in August 2007.
Former commandant challenges long-standing conviction
Mr Donohoe was convicted over an altercation with Lieutenant Colonel John Maloney. The allegation involved him poking the officer’s shirt with his finger and using insulting language during the incident on August 10th, 2007.
He denied the assault and was convicted by a board of Defence Forces members. In 2015, a military judge at McKee Barracks fined him 10 days’ pay and ordered a reduction in salary.
His earlier attempt to overturn the verdict was dismissed by the Court of Appeal in March 2017. The Supreme Court later refused leave to appeal in March 2020.
What evidence is being put before the Court of Appeal?
At the latest hearing, counsel for Mr Donohoe argued that two affidavits contained information capable of supporting his claim that he had been targeted by senior officers before the case went to trial.
The proposed evidence came from a former Army captain and a flight sergeant. Mr Donohoe’s legal team claims that the captain was privately approached by Lieutenant Colonel Maloney and another officer, and was encouraged to make a complaint against him.
Eanna Mulloy, representing Mr Donohoe, described the alleged conduct as evidence of animosity towards his client. He argued that the captain was “leaned on” and that the approaches may have prompted her complaint.
However, the judges questioned whether the evidence went far enough to establish that the complaint was false or improperly obtained.
Judges question meaning of “pressurised”
Judge Isobel Kennedy noted that although Mr Donohoe’s case referred to the captain being “pressurised”, the captain’s affidavit did not use that term. Instead, she said she had met two people before making her complaint and indicated that she might not have complained but for those approaches.
The judge said that being prompted to make a complaint was significantly different from being pressured into making a false one.
Judge Charles Meenan also raised the question of whether the proposed evidence directly challenged the testimony that had led to the conviction. He said that evidence suggesting senior officers had been hostile towards Mr Donohoe would not, by itself, amount to new facts unless it undermined the evidence given at the original proceedings.
Military prosecution disputes the appeal arguments
The Director of Military Prosecutions opposed the application. Its counsel, Remy Farrell, argued that the appeal focused largely on military criminal procedure and alleged prosecutorial bias rather than demonstrating a lack of evidence or unfairness in the substance of the original trial.
Mr Farrell said the former captain was not claiming that her complaint had been false. Her evidence, he argued, amounted only to an assertion that she had been encouraged to make it.
The prosecution also questioned whether the information could properly be described as newly discovered. It said Mr Donohoe’s legal team had not explained when the information became known to him, why it was unavailable earlier or how it would have been used in a trial.
Mr Mulloy argued that the absence of a victim impact report was another indication that no assault had occurred. The prosecution rejected the wider implications of that argument and maintained that the proposed affidavits did not relate directly to the 2007 altercation.
Judgment reserved
The three-judge Court of Appeal has reserved its decision. The court must determine whether Mr Donohoe has met the legal threshold for introducing new evidence in support of his appeal.
The hearing did not overturn the conviction. It concerned whether the former commandant should be allowed to rely on additional material in seeking to challenge the earlier outcome.
The case remains a matter before the courts, and the allegations made during the appeal have not been determined. Any decision on whether the evidence can be admitted will be delivered at a later date.
Key takeaway from the Court of Appeal hearing
The former Air Corps commandant says newly submitted affidavits support his claim that he was unfairly targeted before his assault conviction. The Director of Military Prosecutions disputes that the material is new or sufficient to undermine the original case. The Court of Appeal has reserved judgment.





