Some of television and cinema’s most beloved characters become far less heroic when their actions are examined closely. This daily trending topic rounds up 27 TV and film characters who fans believe are toxic, selfish, manipulative or simply much less likeable than their stories suggest.
The list is based on fan opinions shared in a Reddit discussion and includes everyone from romantic leads to animated troublemakers. Several entries involve abuse, coercion or unethical behaviour, so this is a discussion of fictional characters rather than a claim that every character is equally harmful.
The daily trending topic: when “good” characters look different on a rewatch
Modern audiences often reassess familiar stories through a different lens. Actions once presented as charming, funny or romantic can look controlling, entitled or irresponsible years later. That shift is especially noticeable when a plot excuses behaviour because a character is attractive, entertaining or ultimately helpful.
Romantic leads under scrutiny
- Edward Cullen from Twilight is criticised for invading Bella’s privacy, controlling her friendships and watching her sleep.
- Emily from Emily in Paris is described by fans as entitled, culturally insensitive and protected by the show’s insistence that she means well.
- Nick Young from Crazy Rich Asians keeps important information from Rachel and fails to support her when his family turns against her.
- Tom from (500) Days of Summer is blamed for romanticising a relationship while ignoring what his partner actually wanted.
- Andy’s boyfriend in The Devil Wears Prada is viewed as unsupportive of her demanding career and long working hours.
Other controversial relationship choices include Dr Jacob in Ted Lasso, whose relationship with Ted’s former wife raises questions about professional boundaries, and Belly in The Summer I Turned Pretty, whose indecision creates a painful triangle involving two brothers.
Familiar protagonists with questionable choices
Not every character on the list is presented as a villain. Some are protagonists whose flaws are softened by narration, nostalgia or comic framing.
- Ross Geller from Friends remains divisive despite the “we were on a break” defence.
- Carrie Bradshaw from Sex and the City is accused of being self-absorbed and a poor friend despite being the show’s central voice.
- Rory Gilmore is remembered as intelligent and kind, but fans also point to entitlement, manipulation and decisions that hurt others.
- Michael Scott from The Office is often reassessed because behaviour once played for laughs may feel less forgivable today.
- Meredith Grey from Grey’s Anatomy and Malcolm from Malcolm in the Middle are both criticised for selfishness, cynicism and frequent impulsiveness.
Heroes, villains and blurred moral lines
The daily trending topic also includes characters whose actions are harder to defend than their heroic reputations suggest. Katniss Everdeen is criticised for focusing on people close to her while placing others in danger. Dumbledore faces backlash for leaving Harry in an abusive home, while Magneto’s repeated conflicts with Charles Xavier prompt questions about how often he should be forgiven.
Wanda in WandaVision is another complicated example. Her grief is central to the story, but fans argue that imprisoning an entire community in a mind-controlled fantasy should not be treated as a minor consequence of heartbreak. Peter Pan, meanwhile, is reinterpreted as a child kidnapper rather than a harmless symbol of eternal youth.
Comedy and children’s favourites are not immune
Several entries show how easily comedic framing can disguise selfish behaviour. Grandpa Joe from Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory is mocked for suddenly finding energy when adventure arrives, despite supposedly being unable to help Charlie at home. Linda Belcher from Bob’s Burgers is described as lovable but regularly impulsive, while the Cat in the Hat is condemned for causing chaos in a children’s story.
Dorothy in The Wizard of Oz, Troy from High School Musical and Owen Wilson’s character in Wedding Crashers also receive criticism for actions that the surrounding story treats more lightly than viewers might today.
Why these characters remain popular
Flawed characters can be more memorable than perfectly virtuous ones. Their contradictions create conflict, comedy and discussion, while strong performances encourage audiences to keep rooting for them. A character can be entertaining, sympathetic or well written without being a good person.
That distinction is the main appeal of this daily trending topic: revisiting favourite films and series can reveal behaviour that earlier audiences accepted without question. Whether fans agree about every example, the debate shows how changing standards affect the way familiar stories are read.
Conclusion
This daily trending topic is ultimately a reminder that popularity does not equal morality. From Edward Cullen and Wanda to Michael Scott and Grandpa Joe, beloved characters can still be controlling, selfish or reckless. Rewatching with a more critical eye does not erase their entertainment value—it simply makes the conversation around them more honest.


