Skip to content
Weather forecastWeather data: CC BY 4.0; temperatures rounded
Advertise

Sections

DailyDigest

Our network

World News

New York plan sets 2032 deadline to close Rikers Island jail

New York City’s mayor has proposed closing Rikers Island by 2032, replacing it with four smaller jails and reducing the detainee population.

New York City has unveiled a renewed plan to close the notorious Rikers Island jail complex by 2032, replacing it with four smaller facilities and reducing the number of people held in custody. The proposal aims to address years of criticism over deteriorating buildings, staffing shortages, inmate deaths and the distance families must travel to visit detainees.

Rikers Island closure plan targets 2032

Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s administration published an 88-page report outlining a new timetable for shutting the jail complex. The plan requires approval from New York City Council, although senior council figures have indicated support for the revised schedule.

Rikers, located on a 413-acre island between Queens and the Bronx, has been the subject of closure plans since 2019. Earlier legislation required the complex to shut by 2027, but progress was delayed by logistical challenges, the Covid pandemic and setbacks during the administration of former mayor Eric Adams.

Dana Kaplan, appointed by Mamdani to oversee the closure, described the proposal as an opportunity to redesign how people are detained in New York City, rather than simply replacing an ageing jail.

Four smaller jails planned across New York City

The mayor’s office says the replacement facilities will be distributed across the city:

  • A Brooklyn jail is scheduled to open by 2029.
  • Two facilities in the Bronx and Queens are planned for 2031.
  • A Manhattan facility is expected by 2032.

Officials argue that smaller, more accessible sites will offer detainees better access to daylight, fresh air and cleaner accommodation. They are also intended to make visits easier for relatives, as travelling to Rikers can take several hours depending on where a family lives.

The complex currently holds more than 6,500 people at a given time. Mamdani wants to reduce the city’s jail population to about 4,100, partly through alternatives to detention for some people awaiting trial and by speeding up the pretrial legal process.

Correction officers challenge proposed population cap

The proposed reduction has drawn opposition from New York City’s correction officers’ union. The union argued that imposing a fixed limit on available jail beds could create safety risks, particularly if people accused of violent felony offences were released without appropriate safeguards.

Kaplan rejected that criticism, saying it was possible and desirable for New York City to hold fewer people in jail. The disagreement highlights one of the central challenges facing the closure project: building new facilities while also changing the system that determines who is detained and for how long.

Rikers has faced years of scrutiny

Rikers has acquired notorious nicknames, including “Gladiator School” and “Torture Island”, because of its troubled conditions. The site has housed high-profile detainees such as Tupac Shakur, DMX and Harvey Weinstein, but its wider reputation has been shaped by concerns about violence, inadequate staffing, crumbling infrastructure and deaths in custody.

The jail complex has recorded nine inmate deaths this year, according to the supplied report. Last year, a federal judge removed Rikers from direct city control and appointed an independent official to make decisions about the facility.

In his report, Mamdani described the jail as a product of deteriorating infrastructure and said officials had a moral responsibility to close it. The new proposal therefore combines a construction programme with measures intended to reduce the need for detention.

Mental health and rehabilitation measures included

The plan includes $146 million for mental health and substance-use treatment, as well as education and vocational programmes inside and outside the jails. The administration also wants to create hundreds of therapeutic housing beds for people with serious mental health needs.

Kaplan said 100 therapeutic beds had already opened at Bellevue Hospital in Manhattan, allowing 100 people to move away from Rikers Island. Other proposed measures include:

  • More alternatives to detention for eligible people awaiting trial.
  • Online options to make it easier for families to post bail.
  • Faster handling of pretrial cases.
  • Expanded treatment and education services.

What happens next?

New York City Council must approve the updated closure timeline before the programme can proceed. The city will also need to complete the replacement facilities while maintaining safe custody arrangements during the transition.

The debate over Rikers is about more than the future of one jail. It also concerns the balance between public safety, detention policy, mental health support and the rights of people awaiting trial. If the plan succeeds, New York will replace a remote and widely criticised complex with a more distributed system and a smaller detainee population.

The key test will be whether the city can meet the 2032 deadline while delivering the promised treatment, legal and rehabilitation services. For now, the proposal marks the latest attempt to turn a long-delayed closure commitment into a workable timetable.

Suggested stories

Join the conversation

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Guide & Tools