The proposed Navan rail line has triggered a sharp environmental dispute in Co Meath, with Randal Plunkett, the 21st Baron of Dunsany, saying he may sell his family’s art collection and household contents to fund legal opposition to the route.
Plunkett argues that the preferred alignment for the 34km electrified railway would cut through the Dunsany Nature Reserve, damaging mature woodland and fragmenting an important wildlife habitat. Irish Rail says the route would support planned development and provide a major sustainable transport link for Navan and surrounding communities.
Navan rail line route faces opposition from Dunsany estate owner
Irish Rail published its preferred route last week for a railway intended to provide direct DART services between Navan and Connolly Station in Dublin. The proposal includes four new stations at Dunshaughlin, Kilmessan, Navan Central and Navan North.
The route largely follows the alignment of a former railway line that closed in 1963. However, part of the proposed corridor would pass through the Dunsany estate, including a section of the nature reserve’s central 192-hectare block.
The wider estate covers approximately 650 hectares. Plunkett says the route would not simply affect a small strip of land, but would disrupt ecological connections across the reserve through construction activity, tree clearance and the permanent presence of railway infrastructure.
Why the reserve matters
Plunkett stopped livestock farming on the estate in 2014 and ended the use of fertilisers, herbicides and pesticides. The reserve became a member of the European Rewilding Network in 2020, the first site in Ireland to do so.
According to Plunkett, the changes have been followed by a 35 per cent increase in bird populations and a doubling of insect populations. The estate has also recorded the first confirmed breeding of great spotted woodpeckers in Co Meath and the return of breeding red kites.
Thirteen of Ireland’s 54 red-listed bird species have been recorded on the estate, he said, while eight of the country’s nine native bat species have confirmed maternity roosts there. The woodland lies beside a special area of conservation near the River Boyne.
Legal challenge could extend to European courts
Plunkett has prepared a 54-page submission for the Irish Rail consultation, including a detailed assessment of bats. He intends to resubmit his observations before the second public consultation deadline on December 10th.
He has also criticised the assessment of the proposed railway’s effects on biodiversity and on the River Skane, which runs through the reserve and is classified as being “at risk”. The estate has worked voluntarily with Inland Fisheries Ireland and the Office of Public Works on restoration efforts for the river.
The baron said he would pursue the matter through the European courts if necessary. He has indicated that funding the legal campaign could involve auctioning paintings and other contents of Dunsany Castle.
His objection is not to expanding public transport in principle. He said he supported urgent improvements to transport in the Greater Dublin Area and Meath, but opposed any route that would destroy the reserve. He has pointed to alternative alignments through Dunshaughlin, Ratoath and Ashbourne, arguing that they would serve larger populations while avoiding Dunsany.
Irish Rail defends preferred alignment
Irish Rail said the preferred route was selected because it follows the historic railway alignment and was also identified as the preferred option by Meath County Council.
The organisation said the project would significantly improve commuting to and from Navan, as well as travel from intermediate stations. It added that the route was chosen to support planned development and could allow services to operate every 15 minutes.
The competing priorities are now clear: the project promises a long-awaited public transport connection for Meath, while the Dunsany estate argues that the environmental cost of the selected corridor would be permanent and unacceptable.
What happens next?
The consultation process remains central to the dispute. Plunkett plans to submit further observations by December 10th, after which the project will continue through its assessment and planning stages.
- The preferred route includes four proposed stations.
- The railway would be electrified and linked to direct DART services to Dublin.
- The proposed corridor would pass through part of the Dunsany Nature Reserve.
- Further submissions are expected before the December 10th consultation deadline.
- Plunkett says he may pursue legal action in Ireland and at European level.
The final decision will have to weigh transport demand, planning considerations, biodiversity protections and the potential impact on the River Skane. Until the consultation and subsequent approvals are complete, the preferred route is not the final railway alignment.
Navan rail debate puts transport and rewilding in direct conflict
The Dunsany dispute highlights a difficult question for Ireland’s infrastructure plans: how can new public transport links be delivered while protecting habitats that have been restored over decades?
For Irish Rail, the historic alignment offers a route intended to support population growth and regular services for commuters. For Plunkett, the ecological value of the reserve cannot be measured solely by the percentage of land occupied by tracks.
The consultation will provide the next formal opportunity for those competing arguments to be assessed. The central issue is whether the Navan rail line can be redesigned to meet transport objectives without severing the wildlife network at the heart of the Dunsany reserve.
The key takeaway: the Navan rail line remains at the preferred-route stage, but opposition from the Baron of Dunsany could lead to a major legal and environmental challenge before construction can proceed.





