More than 300 former Christian Brothers have been joined as defendants to a child sex abuse claim through a newspaper advertisement published on Tuesday, after the religious order declined to nominate a representative for cases involving historical abuse claims.
The High Court authorised the alternative method of serving notice on 314 men, rather than requiring lawyers to locate and serve each person individually. The development is the latest stage in a legal strategy that has been criticised by the court and by senior Irish politicians.
Why the former Christian Brothers were named
The Christian Brothers is an unincorporated association. Unlike most religious congregations involved in historical abuse litigation, it has chosen not to put forward a nominee to represent the congregation in claims against it.
As a result, claimants are required to join surviving members who belonged to the congregation during the periods relevant to their allegations. This can involve large numbers of people who are not alleged to have committed abuse, or to have known about it.
The advertisement makes clear that the inclusion of the former brothers as defendants does not, by itself, suggest that they had responsibility for or knowledge of the crimes at issue.
About 100 surviving members who were members of the congregation at the relevant time are being served through the Christian Brothers’ headquarters in Dublin. The remaining notices were published after the High Court approved newspaper advertising as a practical way to notify those whose current addresses may be difficult to establish.
Second newspaper notice follows August advertisement
Tuesday’s notice follows an earlier advertisement published in August, which named 341 former Christian Brothers in connection with another case. The advertisements are being used after High Court judge Mary Rose Gearty granted permission in three claims for notices to be served in this way.
The notice published in the Irish Daily Star relates to a claim involving former brother Liam Coughlan, who died in prison in October while serving sentences for abusing children in primary schools in Kilkenny and Portarlington.
The claim concerns alleged abuse between September 1974 and June 1976. Coughlan had already been convicted in relation to the claimant. He was jailed in 2023 for indecently assaulting former pupils at CBS primary school on Stephen Street in Kilkenny during the 1970s. Earlier this year, he was also convicted of sexually abusing former students at the CBS primary school on Patrick Street in Portarlington during the 1980s.
The notice states that any named man who does not respond within 42 days may face an application for judgment in default of response. It also directs future correspondence to the Christian Brothers European Province Centre on Griffith Avenue, Dublin 9.
Judge and Government criticise legal approach
Judge Gearty has described the Christian Brothers’ refusal to nominate a representative as “morally extraordinary” and obstructive. The approach has made it more difficult and costly for survivors to pursue claims, according to the legal arguments reported to the court.
Taoiseach Micheál Martin said the Christian Brothers should accept responsibility for abuse perpetrated by some of its members and compensate survivors. He said too many survivors had been required to go through the courts for too long.
Tánaiste Simon Harris described the position taken by the order as insulting and painful for victims and survivors. He said religious institutions could enable the courts to progress cases by putting forward a nominated person.
The Government’s comments concern the order’s legal structure and its decision not to provide a nominee. They do not determine the outcome of any individual civil claim, which remains a matter for the courts.
More cases may involve public notices
Lawyers for the claimants have indicated that further applications may follow. When permission was granted for the notices, barrister Andrew Nugent said the firm involved had another 13 cases in which it might seek similar authorisation.
Many historical claims relate to events alleged to have occurred during the 1970s and 1980s. Because of the age of the cases and the number of former members who may be connected to the relevant periods, further former Christian Brothers could be publicly joined to proceedings even where they have no alleged connection to the abuse.
The August advertisement reportedly caused distress among some of the men named. Lawyers representing three former brothers told the High Court that their clients were upset by being publicly joined to a case. One lawyer also said there had been no response to a request for an indemnity from David Gibson, head of the Christian Brothers in Ireland.
What happens next in the case
The individuals named in Tuesday’s notice have 42 days to respond to the claim. If a response is not filed, the claimant may ask the High Court to consider judgment in default, subject to the court’s rules and any relevant applications.
The notices are a procedural consequence of the order’s decision not to nominate a representative. Being named in the advertisement is not a finding of liability, and the source material specifically states that the former brothers’ inclusion does not imply responsibility for, or knowledge of, Coughlan’s crimes.
For survivors, however, the litigation illustrates the practical difficulties of pursuing historical child abuse claims decades after the alleged events. The dispute over representation is now central to the proceedings, while the underlying claims continue through the High Court.
Key takeaway: The latest Breaking News development is a High Court-approved newspaper notice naming 314 former Christian Brothers in a child sex abuse claim. The men’s inclusion does not establish wrongdoing, while the court will determine how the civil proceedings progress.





