The High Court has ordered redactions to affidavit evidence submitted in a dispute involving Michael Flatley, finding that parts of the material were irrelevant, overly personal and covered by legal privilege.
The ruling concerns a €200,000 sum lodged with the court following a dispute connected with Castlehyde, the Lord of the Dance star’s property in north Cork. The substantive application to place a charge over the money is due to be heard by a different judge next month.
High Court ruling in Michael Flatley dispute
Judge Eileen Roberts made the decision during a pretrial motion. Flatley’s legal team had asked the court to remove specific passages from an affidavit sworn by his former solicitor, Maxwell Mooney, as well as an affidavit submitted by his former financial adviser, Des Walshe.
The applications involved claims about the use of legally privileged information and the inclusion of personal material in written evidence. Both sides disputed the relevance and accuracy of some of the statements filed in the proceedings.
According to the judgment, Flatley argued that privileged material had been used in a way that prejudiced his position in the Castlehyde proceedings. He also maintained that parts of the affidavits contained personal allegations that served no proper purpose and were included to cause embarrassment.
What the judge said about the affidavits
Judge Roberts said it was reasonable for Mr Mooney to explain the basis on which he had received instructions from Mr Walshe on Flatley’s behalf. However, she found that it was not appropriate for Mr Mooney to exhibit Mr Walshe’s affidavit in his own affidavit.
The judge directed that the exhibited affidavit be removed from Mr Mooney’s evidence. She also found that large sections of Mr Walshe’s affidavit were not relevant to the application concerning the €200,000 held in court.
In her assessment, parts of the affidavit were “highly personalised”. The judge said many of the personal details were unnecessary to address the issues raised by Mr Mooney’s application.
She further found that some statements were vexatious because they could cause distress to named individuals without serving a purpose connected with the claim before the court.
Legal privilege and fair process
A central issue was whether the affidavits disclosed material protected by legal professional privilege. Judge Roberts said Mr Walshe’s affidavit referred to and disclosed legal advice relevant to the separate Castlehyde proceedings, over which Flatley continued to claim privilege.
The court therefore ordered that specified paragraphs be struck out. Rather than requiring entirely new affidavits, Judge Roberts said the amendments could be made through redactions to the existing sworn evidence.
The redacted affidavits will be used when the court deals with the substantive charging application. The judge hearing that application will consider the remaining evidence without the passages excluded by the ruling.
Household names retain the same right to fair process
Judge Roberts also addressed the public attention surrounding the case. She said Flatley was entitled to fair process like any other person involved in legal proceedings.
His status as a household name, she said, did not remove that entitlement simply because his personal and business affairs attracted media interest. The observation underlines the court’s responsibility to ensure that evidence remains relevant and properly connected to the legal issues being decided.
What happens next?
The High Court will hear the substantive application relating to the €200,000 next month before another judge. The redacted versions of the affidavits will form part of the evidence available for that hearing.
The latest ruling does not determine the underlying charging application. It deals with what material may properly remain before the court while that dispute is considered.
The case highlights the limits placed on affidavit evidence in Irish court proceedings: statements must be relevant to the claim, and confidential legal advice cannot be introduced where privilege continues to apply.
Key points from the ruling
- The dispute involves €200,000 lodged with the High Court.
- The proceedings are connected with Castlehyde in north Cork.
- Judge Eileen Roberts ordered redactions to affidavits linked to Michael Flatley’s former solicitor and financial adviser.
- Some passages were found to be irrelevant, highly personal or potentially privileged.
- The substantive application will be heard by another judge next month.
The High Court’s decision means the next stage of the Castlehyde-related proceedings will proceed on a narrower evidential basis. For readers following Irish news and courts coverage, the important distinction is that the ruling concerns the admissibility and presentation of evidence, not the final outcome of the €200,000 claim.





