Skip to content
Weather forecastWeather data: CC BY 4.0; temperatures rounded
Advertise

Sections

DailyDigest

Our network

Breaking News

Affidea ordered to pay €12,000 over racial discrimination claims

Affidea has been ordered to pay €12,000 after the WRC found racial discrimination against an elderly Pakistani woman and her daughter.

A healthcare provider has been ordered to pay €12,000 to an elderly Pakistani woman and her daughter after the Workplace Relations Commission found that they were racially discriminated against during a visit for MRI scans.

The case, heard under Ireland’s Equal Status Act 2000, concerned treatment at an Affidea Diagnostics Ireland Limited clinic in Dundrum on 4 November 2023. The WRC awarded €7,000 to Mehr un Nisa, aged 75, and €5,000 to her daughter, Dr Shereen Gul.

WRC finds discrimination at Dundrum clinic

The commission found that Ms Nisa and Dr Gul were treated differently from other patients during the appointment. The ruling focused on the way staff questioned Ms Nisa’s name and on Dr Gul being prevented from helping her mother in a changing area before several scans.

Dr Gul, who is a GP, told the WRC that her mother’s name was already recorded on Affidea’s system. She said a receptionist nevertheless questioned the name and required further proof of identity.

According to the evidence accepted by the adjudication officer, Dr Gul was given a piece of paper and asked to write down her mother’s name. She said the receptionist responded that it “does not make sense” and that a “correct one” was required. Dr Gul then arranged for a relative to send a copy of her mother’s passport.

She said the exchange took place loudly enough for other people in the waiting area to hear, leaving her embarrassed. The WRC accepted that her mother had been put to extraordinary lengths to establish her identity in a demeaning and disrespectful way.

Different treatment in the changing area

The commission also examined whether Dr Gul was unreasonably prevented from accompanying her mother into a changing area. Affidea relied on infection-control considerations, but Dr Gul said she had seen an elderly Irish patient being assisted by another person.

The adjudication officer, Patricia Owens, accepted that comparison. She found that Ms Nisa was elderly and frail, had a nervous disposition and did not speak English. In those circumstances, the WRC concluded that Dr Gul should not have been prevented from assisting her without clinical input being sought.

The ruling said the two women were treated differently from an elderly Irish patient and rejected Affidea’s description of the incident as no more than a “slight fall-off in service”. The commission found that the receptionist’s conduct was excessive.

Concerns about the receptionist’s evidence

The receptionist, Karen Fitzpatrick, denied making the comments alleged by the complainants. However, Ms Owens described aspects of her evidence as evasive and, at times, disrespectful.

The adjudication officer said she could not reconcile the receptionist’s claim that she could see the appointment on the computer system with the decision to insist that Dr Gul obtain identification because the name was allegedly difficult to spell. The WRC also found that much of the evidence was inconsistent.

Some allegations were not upheld

The WRC did not uphold every complaint made by Ms Nisa and her daughter. Claims that Ms Nisa’s headscarf had been removed in a public area and that she had been pushed by a male staff member were rejected.

Ms Owens concluded that Dr Gul had removed her mother’s headscarf while overwhelmed by what had happened. Dr Gul also accepted that her mother had not been pushed.

The findings therefore related specifically to the treatment surrounding Ms Nisa’s name, identity checks and access to assistance in the changing area. The compensation was awarded under the racial discrimination complaints that were upheld.

Affidea directed to review policies and provide training

Alongside the financial awards, Affidea was directed to review its policies to ensure compliance with equality legislation. The company must also provide diversity and inclusion training for its staff.

The decision highlights the importance of applying patient-identification and infection-control procedures consistently. It also underlines the need for healthcare providers to take account of age, disability, language barriers and a patient’s need for support when applying those procedures.

For patients and families, the case shows that concerns about discriminatory treatment in the provision of services can be brought before the Workplace Relations Commission under the Equal Status Act. The commission can consider whether a person received less favourable treatment because of a protected characteristic, including race.

Why the ruling matters

This Ireland News case is significant because it deals with everyday access to healthcare rather than an employment dispute. It also demonstrates that discrimination may be found through a pattern of unequal treatment, including how a patient’s identity is questioned and whether a family member is permitted to provide reasonable assistance.

The ruling does not suggest that clinics cannot verify identity or impose safety procedures. Instead, it shows that such measures must be applied respectfully and without treating patients differently because of their race, name, language or background.

The clearest takeaway from this Breaking News report is that healthcare organisations must combine robust safeguarding procedures with equal, dignified treatment. The WRC’s €12,000 award and its requirements for policy review and staff training place that responsibility firmly on Affidea.

Suggested stories

Join the conversation

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Guide & Tools