Jerusalem marked the third anniversary of the October 7th attack on Wednesday as families, survivors and protesters gathered across Israel to remember those killed and demand an independent investigation into the security failures that preceded the assault.
The commemorations took place against the backdrop of continuing grief, unresolved questions about the response to the attack and the wider consequences of the conflict in Gaza. Events were held at memorial sites, border communities, the Nova festival location and in cities including Tel Aviv and Jerusalem.
Nationwide commemorations remember victims
Israeli president Yitzhak Herzog began the official remembrance programme by lighting a memorial candle at 6.29am, the time the Hamas-led assault began on October 7th, 2023. He later travelled to Netiv HaAsara, a farming community near the Gaza border that was among the places targeted during the attack.
Services were also held in kibbutzim and other communities close to Gaza. The attack breached the border in more than 100 locations during its first hour, killing about 1,200 people and resulting in approximately 250 hostages being taken to Gaza, according to the source report.
At noon, hundreds of thousands of people observed a moment of silence. At the Nova music festival site, relatives visited memorials for the victims of the massacre, in which about 378 people were killed, most of them young people attending the event.
Protesters demand a state commission of inquiry
Alongside the official ceremonies, demonstrations took place in roughly 400 locations. Protesters renewed demands for a state commission to examine the security and political failures that preceded the attack.
Outside the Knesset in Jerusalem, demonstrators displayed the burnt-out shells of cars belonging to victims of the Nova festival attack. In Tel Aviv, installations were used to convey the scale of the loss, including rows of human figures placed on a beach and portraits positioned around Dizengoff Fountain.
The calls for an inquiry reflect a continuing dispute over accountability. Prime minister Binyamin Netanyahu has rejected personal responsibility for the security breach and opposed calls for an independent investigation. Supporters of an inquiry argue that a full examination is necessary to establish what warnings were received, how decisions were made and why the attack was not prevented.
Netanyahu pledges to continue the war effort
Netanyahu lit a memorial candle and said Israel would “complete the mission”, adding that the country would seek to settle the score with those responsible for the killings. His remarks came as public debate continues over the government’s stated war aims and whether they have been achieved.
A survey released on the anniversary found that fewer than one in five respondents believed the government’s declared goal of “total victory” had been achieved to a significant extent or in full. The survey also indicated that fewer than half of respondents considered Israel safer than it was before October 7th, while almost one-third believed the country was less safe.
The continuing humanitarian cost
The anniversary was also marked by renewed attention to the humanitarian toll in Gaza. Israeli bombardment and ground operations since the attack have killed more than 74,000 people, according to the figures cited in the source report. At least 1,400 of those deaths occurred during the year since a US-brokered ceasefire halted major fighting, although attacks have continued and the disarmament of Hamas has not been secured.
The commemorations therefore carried different meanings for different communities: remembrance for families of Israeli victims, demands for accountability from protesters, and continued concern about hostages, security and civilian suffering across the region.
Why the anniversary matters
- Families continue to seek answers about the security failures before the attack.
- Public opinion remains divided over whether Israel’s war objectives have been met.
- The conflict’s humanitarian consequences continue despite the reduction in major fighting.
- Memorial events keep the experiences of victims, survivors and hostages at the centre of public debate.
Read more
For Irish readers following international affairs, see the latest Ireland news and global current affairs coverage from DailyDigest.ie.
Explore more
Follow wider analysis of international politics, society and major world events through MediaDigest.ie’s news coverage and Luxedigest.org’s international features.
Frequently asked questions
What happened on October 7th, 2023?
A Hamas-led attack began in southern Israel on October 7th, 2023. About 1,200 people were killed and approximately 250 people were taken hostage, according to the source report.
Why are protesters calling for an inquiry?
Protesters want an independent state commission to investigate the security and decision-making failures that preceded the attack, including whether warnings were missed or inadequately acted upon.
How was the anniversary observed?
Israelis attended memorial services, demonstrations and commemorative installations across the country. A nationwide moment of silence was held at noon, while ceremonies took place in communities along the Gaza border and at the Nova festival site.
Conclusion
The third anniversary brought Israel’s unresolved questions into sharp focus. While memorial ceremonies honoured the victims of October 7th, protests showed that many Israelis still want a transparent investigation into the failures that made the attack possible. The central takeaway is that remembrance, accountability and the humanitarian consequences of the conflict remain inseparable from the country’s national debate.
